Monica's favorite gadget
for slicing apples
This gets a lot of use in my kitchen. In one motion, it cuts perfect apple slices. Works great for slicing caramel apples, too!

Comparing Apples to Apples--the best for eating & cooking

Seems like every time I plan to cook with apples, I can't remember which ones are best for pie or muffins or applesauce. I'd like to try some of the newer varieties, but which ones? I end up googling or hunting for information in the apple aisle at the grocery store. There are so many varieties of apples, it can get overwhelming trying to choose.

That's why I decided it would be helpful to compile some tips for choosing apples and put them in a fact sheet to print out and always have available. No more hunting around for info every time I need to buy apples. Below you will find my apple fact sheet that you can download and print. It would be handy to keep it in a folder or notebook with your cookbooks. That's where I put mine.

One disclaimer, though. I didn't find 100% agreement on the best use for every apple listed on the fact sheet. That's why I compiled the information from several reputable sources (US Apple Association, Cook's IllustratedPick Your Own) and summarized recommendations where I found the most agreement. Your individual tastes and preferences should ultimately guide which apples you use.

Here's the apple fact sheet in downloadable form followed by the complete content of the fact sheet for you to view in the remainder of this post.

Apple Comparison Sheet


This is a summary of recommended uses for some of the more popular apple varieties. Some apples are better suited for eating raw because of their texture and flavor, others are better for pies and baking because they hold their shape when cooked, and others have the texture and flavor for better applesauce.

KEY: =highly recommended =recommended =not recommended
Baldwin Tart,crisp, great for baking
Braeburn Crisp, all-purpose
Cameo Crisp, tart, juicy
Cortland Tart,crisp;slow to brown
Crispin Sweet, firm
Empire Sweet,crisp,firm
Fuji Sweet,crisp,juicy
Gala Mild,sweet,crisp
Golden Delicious Sweet, juicy, best all-purpose
Granny Smith Tart, crisp, juicy, great in salads
Honey Crisp Sweet,crisp
Idared Tart,crisp,firm,store well
Jonagold Both sweet & tart
Jonathan Sweet,acidic
McIntosh Sweet,juicy,less firm
Pink Lady Sweet, crisp
Red Delicious Bland, crisp
Rome Beauty Sweet,firm
Stayman Juicy,tart,store well

Summary of recommendations:

  • Raw for snacking and salads—Personal taste and preferences vary widely—it’s up to you whether  you prefer sweet or tart. Fuji and Honey Crisp are currently the most popular varieties.
  • Pies and baking—Choose only apples that hold their shape well during cooking. Golden Delicious, Baldwin, Cortland, and Idareds are highly recommended by Cook’s Illustrated.
  • Sauce—Choose sweeter apples if you prefer unsweetened or low-sugar applesauce.  Gala, Rome Beauty, Stayman, and Golden Delicious are highly recommended.
  • Juice—Choose a combination of apples to achieve the sweet/tart flavor you prefer. Most apples are good juicers; Honey Crisp is considered a good choice for a balance of sweet and tart.
  • Freezing—(not on chart) Golden Delicious, Rome Beauty, Stayman, Jonathan, Granny Smith.

Try a mixture of apple types in a single recipe. Experiment and find the ones that best suit your taste.

Measurement guidelines:  (this cannot be exact since apple sizes vary)

  • One pound of apples = approx. 2 large, 3 medium or 4 small apples
  • 1 medium apple (tennis ball size) = 1 cup chopped apple
  • One pound of apples yields approx. 3 cups of chopped apple or 2-1/2 cups of sliced fruit
  • Two pounds of apples is enough for an average 9” pie


view on Amazon:  my favorite apple slicing tool

My personal favorite eating apple used to be Fuji. But recently Honey Crisp has become my favorite. What is your favorite apple for eating or cooking?

Make it a Yummy day!

Other apple posts that may interest you:


Posted on Wednesday, November 3rd, 2010

Home    |    Recipes    |    Archives    |    About The Yummy Life    |    Contact
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to and affiliated sites.
Privacy Policy - © 2024 The Yummy Life - All rights reserved