The Yummy Life

Baked Potato Bar

For A Family Dinner or Party Buffet


Subscribe to my newsletter:
and get a free eBook instantly
Share this with your friends:

This wasn't what I'd originally planned on for today's post. But, yesterday it snowed like crazy, temperatures were in the single digits, and I didn't want to go to the grocery store. So, I opened my fridge to see what kind of leftovers I had inside. Turns out that I had some of my Thick and Hearty Steak Chili, and I had a couple of baked potatoes leftover from a recent batch of Baked Potato Soup. Yay! Those two ingredients were a good start to making Loaded Baked Potatoes. So, dinner and today's post were well underway. Sometimes it's the unplanned, spontaneous meals that turn out to be the best.

Take a look at that photo above. Does that not scream comforting, hearty, & delicious?!? Perfect on a cold, snowy day. It made a tasty one-dish meal, but it also has possibilities for expanding into a versatile, fun, build-your-own baked potato bar. This meal is fun for a regular family dinner, but it's also an easy, fun way to feed a crowd. One of things I like about a build-your-own entree is that I don't have to worry about accommodating individual tastes, allergies, picky eaters, vegetarians, etc. This way there is something for everyone. And, did I mention how delicious these loaded baked potatoes are? Yummy is the word.

Did you know? The potato is an excellent source of vitamins and minerals. One medium potato provides a healthy dose of magnesium, iron, potassium, fiber, vitamin C and niacin. Find more nutrition information here.

This is so easy. You need baked potatoes and a variety of toppings. You can offer a few toppings, or go wild with lots of options. If you're cooking for your family, this is a great way to combine some healthy ingredients with some splurge ingredients and make something everyone will eat.  Here's how I prepare my potatoes and a list of toppings to consider.

PREPARE THE POTATOES

  • If possible, purchase potatoes that are a uniform size so they cook evenly. I prefer russets for baking.
  • Scrub them under water and dry them off.
  • Spray or rub them with oil.
  • Use a metal fork to poke a few holes in each potato. (This keeps them from exploding when they cook. Don't do this too far ahead of baking or the fork holes will oxidize and turn dark.)
  • Put them on a rimmed baking sheet, and bake at 400 degrees for 50-60 minutes, until soft.
  • If you're baking potatoes ahead for a party, the hot, baked potatoes can be stored in a cooler for up to 4 hours. Seriously. They keep really well this way. Preheat the cooler with hot water before hand; empty and dry it right before adding the hot potatoes. (Here's a link to more information about preparing baked potatoes for a crowd.)
  • When it's time to serve, cut potatoes longways across the top of each potato and squeeze the ends together to open the potato.

plain potato

 

PILE ON THE TOPPINGS. Here are some to choose from:

Basics:

  • salt
  • freshly ground pepper
  • butter (try whipped, herbed, or garlic butter)
  • sour cream (I use light) or yogurt

Cheese:

  • shredded cheddar or jack
  • crumbled blue or feta
  • grated Parmesan

Fresh herbs and seasonings:

  • chopped fresh basil, cilantro, oregano, or dill
  • crushed red pepper
  • seasoned salt
  • chopped chives

Meats:

  • chili (see my recipe for Thick and Hearty Steak Chili)
  • taco meat
  • fajita chicken or beef
  • pulled pork (see my recipe for Slow Cooker Pulled Pork)
  • crumbled bacon (use the real thing--so much better than those bits in a jar)
  • chopped ham
  • smoked salmon
  • chopped salami or pepperoni

Vegetables:

  • chopped scallions or red onions
  • steamed broccoli, green beans, or asparagus
  • grilled corn
  • beans (canned black beans or chili beans)
  • chopped fresh tomatoes
  • chopped sun-dried tomatoes
  • sauteed spinach
  • sauteed mushrooms
  • grilled onions
  • roasted red peppers
  • sliced jalapenos (fresh or from a jar)
  • thawed frozen peas (no need to cook them)
  • chopped avocados or guacamole

Sauces & dressings:

  • salsa
  • barbecue sauce (see my recipe for 3 Barbecue Sauces)
  • gravy
  • alfredo sauce
  • nacho sauce
  • blue cheese or ranch salad dressing
  • marinara sauce - or other red Italian sauce (see my recipe for Marinara Sauce)
  • pesto (see my recipe for Classic Pesto)

My loaded potato (below) has chili, light sour cream, shredded sharp cheddar cheese, bacon crumbles, and chopped scallions. Pretty darn tasty considering it was an unplanned meal made from leftovers from my fridge. Fritos sprinkled on top would be a good, crunchy finishing touch.

potatoes with bar

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Want an even healthier option? Serve baked sweet potatoes in place of or in addition to baked white potatoes. Check out this post: 

sweet pot thumbnail  Baked Sweet Potato Bar 

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Whatever potato type you prefer, whatever toppings you like, there's a way to customize this recipe to satisfy everyone!

loaded potato

What do you like on a baked potato? Have I left anything off of my list of toppings?

Make it a yummy day!

Other recipes you may like:

Link directly to this recipe Print this recipe
Baked Potato Bar
By Monica
Ingredients
  • Baking potatoes (russets recommended)
  • Olive oil
  • TOPPING POSSIBILITIES--
  • Basics: salt, freshly ground pepper, butter, sour cream (or yogurt)
  • Cheese: shredded cheddar or jack, crumbled blue or feta, grated Parmesan
  • Fresh herbs and seasonings: chopped fresh basil, cilantro, oregano, or dill; crushed red pepper; seasoned salt; chopped chives
  • Meats: chili, taco meat, fajita chicken or beef, pulled pork, crumbled bacon, chopped ham, chopped salami or pepperoni, smoked salmon
  • Vegetables: chopped scallions or red onions; steamed broccoli, green beans, or asparagus; grilled corn; canned black or chili beans; chopped fresh tomatoes or sun-dried tomatoes; sauteed spinach; sauteed mushrooms; grilled onions; roasted red peppers; sliced jalapenos; thawed frozen peas; chopped avocados or guacamole
  • Sauces & dressings: salsa; barbecue sauce; gravy; alfredo sauce; nacho sauce; blue cheese or ranch salad dressing; marinara sauce - or other red Italian sauce; pesto
Directions
--Scrub potatoes under water and dry them off.
--Spray or rub potatoes with oil.
--Use a metal fork to poke a few holes in each potato.
--Put potatoes on a rimmed baking sheet, and bake at 400 degrees for 50-60 minutes, until soft.
--If baking potatoes ahead for a party, the hot, baked potatoes can be stored in a cooler for up to 4 hours. Preheat the cooler with hot water before hand; empty and dry it right before adding the hot potatoes.
--When it's time to serve, cut potatoes longways across the top of each potato and squeeze the ends together to open the potato.
--Serve with a variety of toppings.
Print this Recipe Share this Recipe



Posted on Wednesday, January 12th, 2011
Subscribe to my newsletter and get a free eBook!
Enter your email address below and I'll send new recipes from the Yummy Life directly to your inbox (about one per week). I'll also start you off with a free copy of my eBook: 21 amazing and healthy salad and dressing recipes.
We NEVER spam or sell your information.



Post a comment
56 Comments
Florian @ frenchyscuisine.com says:
Nice and original way to stuff potatoes, thanks :)
Reply Posted 3 years ago
Monica says:
Thanks for the nice comment, Florian. :-)
Reply Posted 3 years ago
Melynda@ Moms Sunday Cafe says:
This is such a fun way to entertain a group of hungry folks, thanks for all the suggestions.
Reply Posted 3 years ago
Monica says:
Hi Melynda. There's really no end to the toppings you can pile on to these potatoes. It's a fun way for everyone at the table to get creative.
Reply Posted 3 years ago
Betty says:
This will work for our lunch at work, you think like me and now I can show them what a loaded potato bar should look like.  
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Jen says:
Great idea!
Reply Posted 3 years ago
Monica says:
Thanks, Jen! :-)
Reply Posted 3 years ago
joycee says:
this is going to be dinner! I am forever seaching for new ideas and this one would really make us all happy. Simple, but I could make it decadent! This is too good not to share on Facebook!
Reply Posted 3 years ago
Monica says:
Hi Joycee! So glad you like this idea. It is a great way to please everyone. I vote for decadent! :-)
Reply Posted 3 years ago
Rich says:
Ha! Buffets of any sort are great in my book, especially if they can reproduce what's shown in that photo of yours. Monica, I can honestly say that is the best-looking baked potato I have ever seen in my life.
Reply Posted 3 years ago
Monica says:
Thanks, Rich! That's quite a compliment. Very kind of you. That potato tasted good, too!
Reply Posted 3 years ago
emily says:
You've inspired dinner tonight. Thanks for the great ideas!
Reply Posted 3 years ago
amy says:
This is the second year that we have had a potato bar for our graduation parties. It is always a big hit!
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Monica says:
Hi Amy. That's great to hear. It's a good way to have "something for everyone" at a big party, since they can customize their potato however they like. Thanks for stopping by and commenting.
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Julie says:
We are planning an end of summer graduation/college send off party.
Since you have done the potato bar before, can you give me a few pointers?  We expect to have 200 people.  I am most concerned about cooking all of those potatoes and keeping them warm over the course of 3 hours.  Any suggestions that would help me in this new endeavor would be greatly appreciated!
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Monica says:
Hi Julie. Sounds like a fun party. This is a perfect menu for feeding a big crowd. I haven't done potato bars for more than 100 people, but the same principles apply. Baking that many potatoes and keeping them warn is the biggest challenge. I recommend reading the tips from EllensKitchen.com (the link is in my post above under "preparing the potatoes"). Her tips for baking and keeping the potatoes warm are great.
--Load up baking sheets with raw potatoes and see how many you can bake at one time in your oven. (It helps to have them on baking sheets so that you can rotate them easily during their baking time).
--Use large coolers that have been pre-heated with hot water for holding the hot baked potatoes--they'll stay hot for at least 4 hours. First fill them with raw potatoes to see how many will fit, and then determine how many coolers you will need.
--You can bake 2 batches and keep the first batch warm in the coolers while you're baking the 2nd batch.
--If you can't bake 200 potatoes in 2 batches in your oven, I'd recommend you ask a friend or two to bake some of them in their ovens. Figure out how many helpers you need to get a total of 200 potatoes. (When I helped with a potato bar for 100 teachers, a friend who had access to a church kitchen with big ovens baked all of the potatoes there. That's a great option, if available.)

Hope that helps. Let me know if you have any more specific questions. Hope your party is a great success!
Reply Posted 2 years ago
jennifer says:
Baked potatoes are a daily event in our house so I am thankfull for so many suggestions on fillings as sometimes I completely run out of ideas.  Great article.
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Monica says:
Thanks, Jennifer. I'm glad you stopped by. :-)
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Lois Wallace says:
I am planning on having a Potato Bar for the residents of our Mobile Home Park  this Christmas season. We plan on Christmas Caroling through the park and after I would like something different from the same ole same ole cookies, cupcakes. etc
Do you have some great idea for the table set up for the potato's and items. We only have 38 people so keeping the potato's hot is no problem.
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Monica says:
Hi Lois. Oh gosh--I just noticed that I hadn't responded to this. So sorry for the delay. I'm glad you're not doing this until Christmas! What a fun Christmas Caroling after-party idea. Regarding set up, I recommend setting the table up with the ingredients grouped in a logical order for piling them on the potatoes. For example, have the potatoes at the end of the table by the plates, then the chili or saucy topping, then veggies, then cheese/sour cream, then anything for sprinkling on top like bacon crumbles, chopped onions, etc. This way the ingredients get added to the potatoes in the right order. Also, by having like items grouped together, guests can choose their favorite from a group and make better choices. If the toppings are all scrambled up, they may find toppings later in the set up that they would have preferred over what they initially chose. If you have any topping options that aren't easily identifiable, it's helpful to have little signs identifying what they are--especially when you're feeding a large group and can't personally explain the ingredients to people as they move down the line. Hope that helps!
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Lois Wallace says:
That's OK Monica I forgot about my posting to you also. Its now Nov 17th and our party is just about a month away. Instead of the same ole table being set for the buffet I am going to use different sizes of small cardboard boxes on my table . I will put the white tablecloth on first to reach the floor on both sides and boxes on that. Then I am putting on a Christmas tablecloth to cover the boxes making different levels where  each different topping will sit. Also will have a string of white lights laying in different directions in between the Potato and toppings. Will let you know how it turns out.
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Ana says:
Any idea how many potatoes a standard size oven will hold and is it alright to use more than one rack?  I need to bake about 30 pototoes and I'd like to do them all at once.  Any reason not to put them straight on the racks, other than convenience?  Replies will be appreciated!  I had this idea on my own for a baby shower I am co-hosting, but its nice to get additional topping ideas and some specific how-to's - thanks!  Let me add that this is a great way to deal with the meat-eaters vs vegatarians dilema of party hosting.
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Denise says:
Great site!  Thanks for the ideas.  You're very creative. :)
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Jill says:
My oldest daughter is turning 7 this weekend, and as usual I was looking for ideas on what to do for the food. We have always done bbq's. It gets boring having the same thing every year. Since my husband and his family planted potatoes this year, we have an over abundance of them. So I figured, what a great way to use some of them up, A BAKED POTATO BAR OF COURSE!!!! At my previous job, we would have a baked potato bar once a year. Each employee would bring a different topping. It was so much fun! It has been a while since I worked at that job, so I needed a little refresher on what toppings would be good, and not so "origional" on a baked potato. So I came upon your blog, AND I LOVE IT! It is so helpful! Thank you so much! (And I hope my baked potato will look, and taste, as good as yours pictured!)
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Monica says:
Hi Jill. Welcome to The Yummy Life! I love the idea of a potluck for the baked potato bar where everyone contributes a topping. I may try that for a party some time. Great idea! Thanks for sharing. :-)
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Mary Homebody says:
Thanks for the terrific idea of a top-your-own potato bar. I served this for a New Year's Day party with adults and children. We roasted and prepared the potatoes along with a batch of our favorite chili and set all the fixings on the counter. The adults appreciated the option of lighter fare during the season of many treats. The children liked to make their choices of toppings. It was fun, casual, and easy to prepare. We will do this again!
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Monica says:
Hi Mary! So glad your potato bar was a hit. Sounds like everyone enjoyed it--something for all ages. Thanks so much for taking the time to share your experience. I appreciate it very much. Happy New Year!
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Jessica says:
My mom's church did this Potato bar potluck and it was a huge triumph!!  Everyone loved it so much that they have decided to do it again next month!  Thanks so much for the ideas!!  Keep them coming!
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Monica says:
How wonderful to hear, Jessica! I'm anxious to try the potluck idea, myself. Thanks for the enthusiastic feedback. :-)
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Lois says:
Monica
I did the Potato Bar for Christmas Eve at our Club House for 45 people.My oven held all 45 in foil. It was wonderful the people were so amazed when they came in from Christmas Caroling. I baked them 2 hours before and put them in a cooler and 2 hours later they were still hot. I used tiny foil bread pans bought at Walmart for my toppings and sprayed the outsides gold to match my table decorations. I then put them on both sides of my table so the people could go on either side. I put 10 on each side. My toppings I used were----Salsa,Steamed Brocolli, Sliced Black Olives,Chopped Green Onions,Sliced Mushrooms,Mild Pepper Rings,Sour Cream,Butter, and Bacon Bits. I hope this idea give lots of readers ideas!
Happy New Year
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Alanna says:
All the suggested toppings are great!  Thanks a bunch for all the great ideas!  I just wanted to add that I like to use chopped chives in place of scallions for a milder flavor and smaller pieces.  We will be having loaded baked potatoes for dinner tonight!
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Lois says:
Alanna
I like chives too, but to buy them for 40 some people was too expensive, and yes all the scallions in the container were gone by the end of the evening.
Hope your potatoes tonight are yummy!
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Monica says:
Hi Alanna! I love chives. Thanks for suggesting them as an alternative topping.
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Monica says:
Oops, I hit "reply" too soon. Just wanted to add that Lois has a good point. Scallions are a less expensive option for feeding a crowd. But, for a family meal or smaller group, I do like the addition of chives to the potato bar. Thanks to you both!
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Judy says:
Next month we are having a Potato Bar for our monthly luncheon.  I am responsible for the dessert.  What would  you recommend?  Thanks
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Monica says:
Hi Judy. It might be fun to continue with the Bar theme for dessert, too. You could set up an ice cream sundae bar with a selection of toppings to choose from. Or, if you don't want to deal with melting ice cream, you can do that same kind of thing using angel food (homemade or store bought) for a base. I've done this with store bought angel food cakes to make it easier. Have slices of cake, fudge sauce, sliced strawberries, and whipped cream and let everyone assemble their own. That way, they can choose to make it healthier (just strawberries) or more decadent by adding other topping. You can offer other toppings, too, depending on how simple/complicated you want to make it. Here's a previous post with recipes: http://www.theyummylife.com/blog/2011/03/154/Angel+Food+Cake+with+Strawberries+%26+Hot+Fudge+Sauce
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Monica says:
One more thing... I keep the fudge sauce warm in a crock pot when I'm serving this in a dessert bar to a large group.
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Durae says:
We are doing a potato bar at work and I need to cook the potato's the day before.  Do you have any suggestions?
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Monica says:
Hi Durae. I haven't ever baked the potatoes the day before, so I can't be sure what would work best. I assume you'll be able to reheat them somehow at work? If so, it might be easiest to wrap them individually in foil before baking them so they can be more easily reheated in the foil. Plus, I think if you baked them ahead without the foil (the way I normally do it), they might dry up and wither some after being cooled and reheated. If I were you I'd do a test ahead of time. Bake a couple of potatoes (one wrapped in foil and one not), put them in the fridge, and reheat them the next day to see how long it takes and how they hold up. Good luck! :-)
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Lois says:
Durae
I guess this answer will depend on if you will be having the potato bar at lunch.

You can bake the potatoes in foil in the morning when you are getting ready for work. I put 34 potatoes in my oven and they all  baked in  about 1 hr 5minute.(I do not have a large oven) I then loaded them up in my Walmart styrofoam cooler and yours will stay HOT for a least 3 hours.

I have got to put my potato bar pictures from Christmas as I said I would in one of the Posts above.
Good Luck !
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Kelly says:
Thank you everyone for all of the great ideas!
We are having a cookout with about 20 people for Mother's Day, and I'm making 30 potatoes (I know I'm having 2!!!).
The toppings we're going with are
Butter
Sour Cream
Bacon (duh! LOL)
Carmelized onions
Broccoli
Melted Velveeta (in one of those mini Crock Pots)

There will be 8 kids there, and I think this will be a big hit with them as well as the adults.

Reply Posted 2 years ago
Beth says:
Can I use convection oven? Can I cover with foil and also use cooler? Will any cooler work or only styrofoam? Do you fully cook if using cooler or do they keep cooking in cooler? If serving at home, should I use oven to keep warm instead of cooler? Cooking 100 for graduation party. Please reply ASAP!
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Lois says:
Beth    
You can bake in any kind of oven and you can wrap the potatoes with foil. The foil will of course keep them moist and hot longer. Cook the potatoes till fully cooked and you can use any kind of insulated cooler I just had my ole faithful cheap cooler from WalMart. If at home yes I would cook them in the oven and turn it off. In the oven with a lot ( all I could get) in my oven was about 40 and they should keep hot for a least 2 hrs.  I honestly for 100 I would go with 2 coolers.  Good Luck you will see everything will turn out just fine!!
Reply Posted 2 years ago
beth says:
I'm having a hard time finding a decent size Russet Potato. They seem pretty small. Is that OK for a potato bar or do I need to get those Jumbo potatoes? We will also be having Italian Beef, Chicken Wings, Fruit, etc...so do I need those Jumbos that will take longer to cook?
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Monica says:
You can go either way, I guess. If the potatoes are the main coarse, I would want to have big ones. Is there a Sam's or Costco near you? That's where I've purchased large, uniform sized russets in the past. If you can't find big ones, I wouldn't worry about it. Truth is, your guests won't have any expectations about them (the don't know what your original intentions were). Your menu sounds great, and it isn't likely to occur to anyone to question the size of potatoes--whatever that turns out to be.
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Lois says:
Beth
With all the other food you are serving the size of the potato will NOT matter. Take it easy and enjoy!
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Lois says:
Beth

I bought the big ones for my first Potato Buffet and found out that a lot of the women wasted or left at least half their potato. My next one was for a Christmas Buffet and I used different sizes and Bingo I noticed all the women chose the little ones and ate them all and then again I saw a couple split a big one. What ever you want to buy just buy them and like I said before your party will turn out just fine!
Reply Posted 2 years ago
beth says:
Can I scrub and dry the potatoes the night before?
Reply Posted 2 years ago
Lois says:
Beth
Yes you can scrub, dry and wrap with foil and even put oil on them if you're not using foil the night before.

Reply Posted 2 years ago
Dena says:
I have a big group going on the house boat this next week.  Because I am always looking for ways to use the BBQ grill instead of the oven (in the heat) It can be tricky but you can cook the potatoes in the grill like an oven.  (just don't put them over direct heat) Thanks for all the topping suggestions!  I was hitting a brick wall on topping ideas!
Reply Posted 12 months ago
Monica says:
Great tip, Dena. Thank you! I didn't know you could "bake" potatoes on the grill. I'll have to give it a try--as you say, it's a good way to keep the heat out of the kitchen.
Reply Posted 12 months ago
BETSY says:
Thanks for the great ideas and pictures!  I used your ideas to host a "Girls Nite In" this summer, and served your potato bar, and asked each guest to bring either a salad or decadent dessert.  We did nails and face masks while the potatoes cooked, then enjoyed your wonderful bar and toppings, which I premade and put on 2 trays (one for hot items that I needed to heat quickly before serving, and a 2nd tray of cold items which I just pulled out of the fridge to serve. Potatoes were baked on 2 cookie sheets (20 potatoes in all), which I just kept in the oven until each tray was emptied.  We did this outside so messy toppings were not a problem!   Next came the girlie movie, and dessert.  Clean up was a breeze.  Thank you for all the suggestions to make this a relaxing & yummy evening!
Reply Posted 10 months ago
Monica says:
Hi Betsy. You are my kind of girlfriend! What a fun girls night IN you planned. Thanks for sharing your great tips for making the potato bar even easier. Love the hot and cold tray idea for easy last minute heating and serving. So glad you shared. :-)
Reply Posted 10 months ago
Gloria Henninger says:
I have had thyroid cancer and do not have a thyroid.  I'm on the Synthroid, daily, so what do you suggest?
Reply Posted 9 months ago
Monica says:
Hi Gloria. So sorry to hear about your health problems. I have no medical training whatsoever, so I'm afraid I can't offer any advice to you. Wishing you the best. :-)
Reply Posted 9 months ago
Debbie says:
If potatoes temperature does not stay ABOVE 140° degrees, you're asking for food poisioning.  Please don't try to 'hold' them in a cooler.

 Danger Zone is between 40°F and 140 °F

Potatoes are high in protein, neutral PH, and moist - which is the perfect incubator for food poisoning.

http://www.brazoshealth.org/EHS/FoodHand/sick.php

If your cooler is below 135° you'll likely get sick.
If your cooler stays above 135° for a period of time, you'll probably damage warp/melt your cooler interior.
So just not worth the risk !!
Reply Posted 6 months ago


Let's hear what you have to say
Hi, I'm Monica...
Thanks for stopping by! This is a place to chat about the good things in life with a focus on fun, easy, healthy recipes and an occasional yummy splurge thrown in.
Read more about The Yummy Life
Free Email Updates!
Subscribe to my weekly newsletter, and I'll send you a copy of my eBook for FREE!
You'll receive about one email per week with my new recipes and ideas. We NEVER spam or sell your information.








Home    |    Recipes    |    Archives    |    About The Yummy Life    |    Contact    |    Community Discussion Group
Privacy Policy - © 2013 The Yummy Life - All rights reserved